| Edward McInroy Female Athlete of the Year |
Charles Winter Male Athlete of the Year |
|
| 2025 | Jessica Oji | Alex Diorio |
| 2022 | Kylie Prendergast | Benjamin Hauser |
| 2021 | Lauren Belcuore | David Cotugno |
| 2020 | Kayla Parsons | Philmon Mehari |
| 2019 | Kelly O’Connor | Joseph Cullen |
| 2018 | Ashley Reuter | Ryan Cardona |
| 2017 | Megan Leffler | Stephen Russo |
| 2016 | Sarosha Parsons | Garrett Meinhardt |
| 2015 | Casey Garfinkel | Tommy Heller |
| 2014 | Jennifer Su | Chandler Balter |
| 2013 | Jessica Peslak | Jason Estevez |
| 2012 | Nancy Yang | Thomas Caputo |
| 2011 | Kate Schwindel | Jeramy Elkaim |
| 2010 | Casey Tepper | Frank Schwindel |
| 2009 | Natalie Natale | Michael Genovese |
| 2008 | Anne Joseph | Zachary Kane |
| 2007 | Gabrielle Paladino | Brian Asman |
| 2006 | Lauren Aduouf | Brett Garlick |
| 2005 | Ainhoa Burturen | Alfredo Rodriguez |
| 2004 | Sammy Rode | Stuck Joseph |
| 2003 | Jessica Chong | Gerry Leone |
| 2002 | Janice Lee | Michael Evans |
| 2001 | Jennifer Lucich | Patrick Trabucco |
| 2000 | Stephanie DelPreore | Mike Luteran |
| 1999 | Christine Moy | Eric Solomon |
| 1998 | Stacy Diner | Michael Graham |
| 1997 | Jennifer Halpern | David Rosa |
| 1996 | Kelly Erb | Ryan Gillock |
| 1995 | Nicole Sibilia | Adam Neubart |
| 1994 | Kim Busichio | Kevin Donner |
| 1993 | Melissa Salus | Joe Cullen |
| 1992 | Linda Fan | Akito Miyazaki |
| 1991 | Michele O’Toole | Alastair Fordyce |
| 1990 | Debbie Goldklang | Erik Neubart |
| 1989 | Eileen Samolsky | Chris Belcuore |
| 1988 | Marla Bernstein | Jason Altman |
| 1987 | Beth Reynolds | Glen Whitman |
| 1986 | Renne Resky | Scott Klein |
| 1985 | Cindy Theel | Stephen Valentine |
| 1984 | Kathy Joyce | Dan Richmond |
| 1983 | Laurie Litvak | Anthony Nittolo |
| 1982 | Debbie Siegel | Brad Whitman |
| 1981 | Fran Miller | George Alpert & Stan Yagiello |
| 1980 | Kathy McNally | Scott Parsons |
| 1979 | Nan Burns | John Modugno |
| 1978 | Patti Friend | David McLaughlin |
| 1977 | Sherry Glassman | Jeff Campisi |
| 1976 | Mary McKenna | Glenn Rieth |
| 1975 | Greg Campisi | |
| 1974 | Glen Jacobs | |
| 1973 | Steve Milone | |
| 1972 | Steve Shmanske | |
| 1971 | Gary Craig | |
| 1970 | Tom Hoerner | |
| 1969 | Ken Klein | |
| 1968 | Cal Nordt | |
| 1967 | Dave Thurston | |
| 1966 | Bob Dukiet | |
| 1965 | James Higgins | |
| 1964 | Al Cece | |
| 1963 | James Greaves | |
| 1962 | Robert Perkins | |
| 1961 | Peter Smith | |
| 1960 | Don McKay | |
| 1959 | Tim Treat | |
| 1958 | Jay Nickel | |
| 1957 | Paul Havas | |
| 1956 | William Buehler |
